UNCP's All-Americans
| Name | Year(s) | Sport |
| Jamel Allison | 2009 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Mike Baldwin | 1979 | Baseball |
| Gray Barnhardt | 1975 | Track & Field (Indoor) |
| Buddy Batson | 1995 | Wrestling |
| Brittany "BB" Berrier | 2008 | Softball |
| Whitney Beverly | 2008 | Women's Soccer |
| Lefke Boysen | 2007 | Women's Soccer |
| Derick Bradley | 1982-83 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Ray Brayboy | 1967, 1969 | Baseball |
| Larry Bridgewater | 1973-74 | Wrestling |
| Keith Broderick | 2009 | Football |
| Elmer Brown | 1976 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| James Brown | 1982-83 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Derek Brunson | 2003, 2005, 2007 | Wrestling |
| Rosendo "Russ" Bryden | 1996 | Men's Basketball |
| Brent Campbell | 1995 | Wrestling |
| Teresa Carl | 1989 | Women's Basketball |
| Roger Carr | 1982-83 | Men's Basketball |
| Mike Carruthers | 1966-1968 | Baseball |
| Luke Charles | 2011 | Football |
| Russell Clark | 1984-85 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Melanie Cobb | 2008 | Women's Soccer |
| Joel Cofer | 1977 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Rick Coffin | 1971 | Baseball |
| Jason Coker | 2011 | Baseball |
| Ronnie Collins | 1968-1970 | Baseball |
| Sam Council | 1979 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Dwayne Coward | 2003-05 | Wrestling |
| Marion Craddock | 1975 | Track & Field (Indoor) |
| Ted Craig | 1977 | Baseball |
| Ginnell Curtis | 2001-02 | Women's Basketball |
| Jeff Cushing | 1975 | Track & Field (Indoor) |
| Travis "T.D." Daniels | 2011 | Football |
| Alan Davis | 1983 | Wrestling |
| J.J. Davis | 2008 | Wrestling |
| Adam Deese | 2010 | Football |
| Johnny Dial | 1984 | Baseball |
| Tim Dial | 1977 | Wrestling |
| Kevin Dietrich | 2009 | Baseball |
| Tuncay Dilek | 2005 | Men's Soccer |
| Preston Douglas | 1969-70 | Baseball |
| Glen Doye | 1974 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Warren Dumas | 1988 | Wrestling |
| Willie Dye | 1980 | Wrestling |
| Derek Edmonds | 1985 | Wrestling |
| Victor Elk | 1973 | Cross Country |
| Mike Emanuel | 1984-85 | Men's Basketball |
| Maurice "Mo" Eubanks | 2011 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Miguel Ferrer | 2007 | Men's Soccer |
| Joe Gallagher | 1968-69 | Men's Basketball |
| Tom Gardner | 1978 | Men's Basketball |
| John Goetke | 1980 | Baseball |
| Sascha Gorres | 2004 | Men's Soccer |
| Dennis Graham | 1974 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Barbara Green | 1984 | Women's Basketball |
| Damon Green | 1971 | Men's Basketball |
| Hivera Green | 2009 | Football |
| Melanie Grooms | 1991 | Volleyball |
| Arron Gunning | 2005 | Wrestling |
| Everett Hambric | 1975 | Men's Basketball |
| Caylon Hann | 2008 | Football |
| Ken Hedgepeth | 1977 | Baseball |
| Greg Henderson | 1984 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Garry Henry | 1976-79 | Cross Country |
| Garry Henry | 1977-79, 1982 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Roy Heverly | 1987-89 | Wrestling |
| Robbie Higdon | 1995 | Wrestling |
| Willie Hilton | 2004, 2006-07 | Wrestling |
| Collin Hines | 1982 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Justin Hinson | 2009 | Football |
| Chris Horton | 1981 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Bob Hudkins | 1972-73 | Wrestling |
| Rickey Jackson | 1975 | Track & Field (Indoor) |
| Chuck Jones | 1980-81 | Wrestling |
| Dennis Jones | 1972, 1974 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Marvin Jones | 1989 | Wrestling |
| Dewey Kight | 1970 | Baseball |
| Antonio Kilpatrick | 1987-88 | Wrestling |
| Steve LaPrad | 1975-76 | Wrestling |
| Rod Lattie | 1972 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Randy Ledford | 1975 | Baseball |
| Braxton Lewis | 2011 | Baseball |
| David Lewis | 1978-79, 1981 | Cross Country |
| Roylando Lucas | 2004 | Wrestling |
| Matt Lynch | 1975 | Wrestling |
| Dee Major | 1985 | Women's Basketball |
| Ben Majors | 1982-83 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| June Martin | 1979 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Willie Mayes | 1987 | Wrestling |
| Matt McGovern | 2009 | Baseball |
| Kenneth McMillian | 1981-83 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Alphonzo McRae | 1974-75 | Men's Basketball |
| Julius Meekins | 1980-82 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Leon Mercer | 1984 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| David Miller | 1974, 1976-77 | Wrestling |
| Donna Moody | 1983 | Women's Basketball |
| Jeff Moody | 1976, 1979 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Meghan Moore | 2012 | Women's Golf |
| Jason Morales | 2008 | Baseball |
| Leon Morgan | 1992 | Men's Basketball |
| Willis "Junior" Nance | 1978 | Men's Golf |
| Pardon Ndhlovu | 2009 | Cross Country |
| Pardon Ndhlovu | 2012 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Everett Neal | 1980 | Wrestling |
| Tom Neilson | 1976 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Rod Nobles | 1979 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Shane Nolan | 2012 | Wrestling |
| Ron Norman | 1973-74 | Baseball |
| Daniel Ownbey | 2012 | Wrestling |
| Forace Oxendine | 1982 | Baseball |
| Carl Peed | 1970 | Men's Basketball |
| David Phillips | 1973-74 | Track & Field (Indoor) |
| David Phillips | 1972-74 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Curry Pickard | 2003, 2005 | Wrestling |
| George Pone | 1983-84 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Carl Powell | 1980-81 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Tony Reid | 1979, 1982 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Timo Reinkainen | 1992 | Men's Soccer |
| Danielle Richardson | 2005 | Women's Basketball |
| Freddie Richardson | 1983 | Wrestling |
| Joe Robisch | 1990-91 | Men's Basketball |
| Larry Rodgers | 1972 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Rudy Rudacille | 1973 | Baseball |
| Dan Ryberg | 1979 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Jelena Shaw | 2008, 2010 | Softball |
| Gregg Shealy | 1980 | Wrestling |
| Charles Shipman | 1976-78 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Jim Smith | 1972 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Tommy Spencer | 1983 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Christian Staackman | 2005 | Men's Soccer |
| Jay Stainback | 1984-87 | Wrestling |
| Jerry Stancil | 1974 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Joe Stukes | 1986-88 | Wrestling |
| Charles Swindell | 1980-82 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Richard Thompson | 1966 | Baseball |
| Tracy Vann | 1986-88 | Women's Basketball |
| James Wall | 1991 | Wrestling |
| Jordan Walor | 2009-10, 2012 | Golf |
| Bob Watts | 1982 | Track & Field (Outdoor) |
| Russell Weakley | 2010-11 | Wrestling |
| Fred Williams | 2011 | Football |
| Mike Williams | 2010-12 | Wrestling |
| Dan Willis | 1993 | Wrestling |
| Duane Wilson | 1989 | Wrestling |
| Avery Winford | 1990 | Wrestling |
| Corey Winston | 2004 | Wrestling |
